Or rather, Happy Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Day!
(Pardon my sad excuse for piping. I couldn’t find tips, and snipping a star in the corner of a Ziploc bag doesn’t work quite as well. Hence the impromptu chocolate drizzle to disguise teh ugleh.)
(I also wish I had a more autumnal plate for the presentation, but I’m not frickin’ Southern Living, okay?)
I taste test while I’m cooking.
I tasted the crust mixture—Oreos, peanuts, and butter—and said, “Gawd, I could eat this all by itself. Or use it for ice cream topping.”
I tasted the filling mixture when it was at the cream cheese, peanut butter, and sugar phase and said, “Gawd, I could eat this all by itself. Or use it for frosting.”
I tasted the filling at the everything-added phase with a little chunk of peanut butter cup to make sure peanut butter cup and peanut butter cheesecake filling actually went together (because I was doubtful… truly), and made a lot of obscene sound effects.
It would probably fill a 9-inch pan to the rim, but I had only an 8-inch pan, so there were leftovers. I ate them.
(And don’t scream at me about getting WORMS from raw eggs. You get WORMS from eating worm-infested FECES. You might get salmonella from raw eggs if you make a habit of eating dirty, cracked ones, but that’s it. I’ve been enjoying all manner of raw egg-containing batters for 34 years without so much as a tummyache. Eggs come in their very own protective suits of armor. You should be way more worried about contaminated produce, which is naked and vulnerable to exposure to all sorts of crud.)
Not that you can tell so much, but there’s a layer of peanut butter cups inside, too. They either disappeared, or I happened to slice in two spots that didn’t cut through any peanut butter cups. Neither would have occurred if I hadn’t chopped them. Recipe adjusted accordingly.
It didn’t crack. It didn’t collapse in the middle. I covered it with peanut butter cups and frosting because that was the plan, not to hide its flaws—because this was a pretty cake, I kid you not. I may have at long last perfected my technique.
I tasted the frosting—peanut butter cream cheese buttercream—and thought about staying home and eating nothing but cheesecake for Thanksgiving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Angelic Daughter, who isn’t a big peanut butter fan, had a couple spoons of frosting for desert and told me to save the leftovers and I won’t have to worry about desert until the bag is licked clean.
Which is good, because I’m thinking I won’t be bringing any cheesecake home after the gathering tonight, and my kitchen is in no shape to be baking anything else for a while. I have a tendency to be sloppy in my enthusiasm and too spent after my efforts to clean up the mess.
I’d post the recipe, but I’d be really miffed—homicidally so—if some troll lifted it and won a million bucks in the Pillsbury Bakeoff or something. You’ll just have to wait for my cookbook, I guess…