Jul 03 2008
Stop hitting yourself
I’ve read a couple of statements lately of people being put off when writers talk about their unhappiness with something they’ve written. I’m guilty of this, and I’m in plenty of good company, but I’ve been looking at it from a different angle in the past couple of days, and it ain’t pretty.
In my case, minimizing my ability/talent/expectations/everything else is a survival tool I picked up back in the Paleozoic era when I was but wee prey. When you’re at a lofty elevation (say, Cloud Nine), you are an excellent target and therefore more likely to become a target. Even if you’re lucky and the snipers are all lousy shots, sooner or later, you’re bound to get winged. You might survive the shot, but that’s small consolation if the fall from that lofty elevation kills you.
Ergo, upon completing some accomplishment, the safe thing to do is limit any floaty elation you may experience to 5 or 10 seconds, then come back down to earth, present a low profile, and try not to look worthy of a sniper’s attention. Maybe even grasp your arm and look pitiful, since it would be unsporting to shoot you when you’re already done for.
Speaking from three decades of experience, this method serves its purpose. Low expectations often result in being pleasantly surprised by even small rewards, and being knocked from a low perch leaves bruises rather than broken vertebrae.
But.
When you’re trying to sell a product, you have to jump up and down and wave your arms and make some noise to draw attention to it, or no one will know it exists. Okay, now that you have the customers’ attention, what’s your sales pitch?
“This isn’t very good.”
Whoadamn, look at everybody reaching for their wallets to get some of that low-quality merchandise because they feel sorry for you and respect your honesty.
It doesn’t work that way. People expect value for their money. You can’t get around this by giving the product away for free—they expect value for their time, too. They’re not going to give you either (their money or their time) after you tell them you have nothing of value to offer them in exchange.
Time to stop being self-defeating.
If you really believed you’d written worthless garbage, you would have shredded the hard copies and deleted the files from your hard drive in shame, not offered it to someone to read and invited their feedback. Unless you’re some kind of supermasochist who experiences paroxysms of ecstasy upon hearing your writing is an affront to human intellect (in which case, this little confidence pep talk is whistling through your ears right about now because you’re self-stimulating to fantasies of your future 1-star reviews on Amazon), you had to believe there was at least a 50/50 chance you’d hear something positive.
Congratulations! Your confidence has reached the minimum marketability level of 50 percent!
May not sound like much, but it’s actually an excellent, well-balanced position to be in because you’re in no danger of tipping too far to the other side of the confidence teeter-totter and coming off as an arrogant jerk. (Ironically, people have an even less favorable response to “I’m the bestest evah” than to “This isn’t very good.”)
From this well-balanced position, poised in the dead zone between neurotic and insufferable, you should be able, with practice, to avoid assigning value judgments to your work, at least in the presence of potential customers. (Sorry. If there’s a cure for insecurity, I don’t have it. We can learn to leave it at home in its crate when we go out in public, though.)
The process can be broken down into four simple steps:
- Stifle any inclination you may have to tell people how to feel about the story before they’ve even read the first word (or after they’ve read the last, but that’s a whole other topic).
- Tell them what the story is about.
- Tell them where they can find it if they’re interested.
- Fade into the background and let the story do the rest of the talking.
Bottom line: Pretty much everybody worries about not being good enough, but that’s not the connection you want to establish with readers in your promotional efforts.
There will always be plenty of people eager to point out your shortcomings. Let them have that miserable job. Don’t do it to yourself and risk alienating even one person who would have loved your story… if only she’d been tempted to read it.


11/4
11/4
11/25